DVD Review – Simon Philips: Complete

June 23, 2008 in Artists, Education, Music/DVDs, Reviews by JABB

Simon Philips: Complete is another case of two older videos being merged and resold as a single DVD. Its two individual parts being Simon Philips and Simon Philips Returns.

The thing about this DVD is that it doesn’t really reveal to you what you are getting into when you buy/rent it. Certainly there’s no hint as to the nature of the content in the title of the DVD. So I’m going to tell you what you’re getting into. Mostly you’re getting performance and breakdown of music Simon Phillips wrote, along with a couple of solos and some sections on general drumming topics. Some of the general drumming topics include double bass drumming and double bass tuning, timekeeping, coordination, snare drum tuning, and snare drum playing.

The advice he gives is pretty good in many of the areas he talks about and not so good in some of the others. Usually when the advice isn’t satisfactory it’s because he didn’t go in-depth enough as opposed to the advise just being bad. Also, as with most older DVDs, lots of the ideas and advice he give have been done again but better in newer DVDs. You can tell this stuff was big news back in the old days but today much of it has been improved on. I’m searching and failing to say something else about this DVD which means it’s time for the break down.

For content I’m giving it one and a half mics. The majority of the DVD is him talking about his music and how to play it so there’s not way too much in terms of general instructional material.

For presentation I’m giving it half a star. it suffers from a lack of focus and that hurt it’s presentation score.

For extras I’m giving it half a star. There is a printable interview, a performance only mode. Nothing fancy but it’s something.

so it’s a total of two and a half mics.

The word that comes to mind when I think of this DVD is meh.

Rent it if you want but there is better stuff out there.

 

Related Posts
Hola! Yeah, I know it has been a while but now I'm back! To make up for slacking I'm doing a trio of videos to make up for lost time. The three videos come from a new series of instructional videos I discovered on Netflix. A Los Angeles based company called IMV has flooded Netflix with its line of "Behind the Player" (BTP) DVDs. They have videos for guitarists, bassists, and drummers and they feature mostly artists ...
READ MORE
I've been excited to see this one for a while. I was waiting for the promised Blu-Ray version to come out so I could see if the instructional experience is that much better in HD. Alas, my patience expired when I saw it available on Netflix. I saw the preview for this DVD and thought "that guy sounds like a more progressive version of Steve Smith... and I like that." As it turns out Todd Sucherman: ...
READ MORE
This review might be a little nontraditional but you'll have to forgive me because this DVD is quite nontraditional. It's one of those most rare of animals, the drum and bass instructional video. Carter Beauford, (drummer for DMB) and Victor Wooten, (bassist for Béla Fleck and the Flecktones), decided to turn the recording session for Victor's album Yin-Yang into the foundation for an entire drum/bass instructional DVD. This isn't two separate instructional DVDs that Hudson Music ...
READ MORE
If there's any drummer who can claim they've come from the rock and roll jungle it's Matt Sorum. With seven years under his belt, he's the longest sitting Guns N' Roses drummer ever. Matt Sorum was ejected from the band by Axl Rose after he defended Slash's decision to leave. So along with Slash and former Guns N' Roses bassist Duff McKagan they formed Velvet Revolver... which is now on hiatus because their lead singer ...
READ MORE
Today, we examine what makes a drum kit a good kit, and we discuss the differences between top of the line gear.  Simon Phillips is the drummer of the week, and we have news including Thomas Pridgen's departure from The Mars Volta!! Show Notes Direct Download
READ MORE
Coordination & Groove is a video that is pretty much honest about its content. It's a video about coordination and groove, in that order IMO. Alan Schechner (the host) is another one of those working drummers. The kind that we'll probably end up like if we pursue the working drummer career path. Not famous, but then again... who needs fame if you have a job making music with the instrument of your choice? He's also ...
READ MORE
I'm gonna be totally honest and say I had never heard of Randy Van Patten before I rented this DVD and I have a feeling you might not know who he is either. He's a working drummer with a lots of years under his belt and has drummed for lots of people in his time. In other words he's the kind of drummer we aspire to be like but didn't realize it when we ...
READ MORE
     I've just been striking out with a vengeance on my recent Netflix picks for drum reviews and  this is strike 3... good thing I'm not playing baseball. Mike Terrana's Rhythm Beast is very similar to Ian Paice's DVD that I reviewed previously in that there was some confusion as to what I was getting into when I read the description. The description led me to believe that this was a performance/instruction just like the description of Ian Paice's DVD led me to believe it was a ...
READ MORE
So while searching for a story for today, I stumbled across the Hudson Music Youtube channel and found a whole channel for Tommy Igoe's Groove Essentials 2 DVD. This particular clip popped out to me. It's about rideless grooves and how to use them. I found it incredibly useful. Same ole Tommy. However, I noticed he's using Evans heads now where he was using Remo before. Enjoy! [youtube]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GlAuXhP9I5o&feature=related[/youtube]
READ MORE
In keeping with the time honored tradition of taping things and then selling a DVD of said things to people... Hudson Music has released the DVD of last year's Modern Drummer Festival. Way to go guys. Source: Harmony-Central.com Featuring amazing performances and illuminating interviews from eleven of today's greatest drum artists, Hudson Music's new, four-disc, twelve-hour DVD of the 2008 Modern Drummer Festival™ is much more than merely the highlights of the most prestigious, longest-running, largest live ...
READ MORE
DVD Review – Behind the Player: Stephen Perkins
Todd Sucherman: Methods & Mechanics for Useful Musical
Victor Wooten & Carter Beauford: Making Music
DVD Review – Matt Sorum: Licks and Tricks
Drummer Talk 11/05/2009 – What Makes a Good
DVD Review – Alan Schechner: Coordination & Groove
DVD Review – Randy Van Patten: Extreme Drum
DVD Review – Mike Terrana: Rhythm Beast
Groove Essentials Youtube Channel
Hudson Releases Modern Drummer Fest 2008 DVD